Indemnification and Warranty Clauses: The Fine Print That Decides Who Pays

BACK TO INSIGHTS     Alerts

Date Published: 11/13/2026

When a deal goes wrong or a product fails, the indemnification and warranty clauses in your contract usually decide who pays for losses, fees, or repairs. A single sentence you sign can leave your company covering another party’s losses, attorneys’ fees, and judgments, or it can leave you with nothing more than a refund or replacement.

Indemnification: What You Are Promising to Pay

  • It shifts financial risk. In an indemnification clause, one party agrees to cover the other’s losses, damages, and costs. These often include attorneys’ fees, court costs, and judgments.
  • “Defend, indemnify, and hold harmless” are three obligations, not one. Each term can create a separate legal duty, depending on which state’s law governs the contract.
  • Courts read ambiguity against you if you are the one seeking indemnification. Loosely drafted language can leave you without the protection you thought you had.
  • The scope decides the outcome. Key questions include:
    • Does the clause cover defense costs and attorneys’ fees?
    • What event triggers the obligation?
    • Does it apply to claims between the contracting parties, or only to third-party claims?
    • Is it mutual?

Warranties: What You Can Actually Recover

  • Some warranties apply even if they are not written down. Under New Jersey’s Uniform Commercial Code, a sale of goods may carry express warranties, an implied warranty of merchantability, and an implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose.
  • Disclaimers and remedy limits are enforceable only if done correctly. Courts construe them strictly. They may fail if they are not conspicuous, if they are unconscionable, or if they fail of their essential purpose.
  • Exclusive remedy clauses and consequential damages exclusions can limit a buyer to repair, replacement, or a refund, even when the actual losses are far larger.

Construction and Supply Contracts: Added Exposure

  • Typical written warranties cover materials, workmanship, and manufacturer products such as mechanical systems. Manufacturer warranties are often narrow and limited in time.
  • A “good and workmanlike” standard is often implied even when the contract contains no written warranty.
  • One-year correction periods, including those in AIA form contracts, generally require the owner to give written notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure before hiring someone else. Owners do not have to accept patchwork repairs. If the contractor fails to make proper repairs, the owner can hire another contractor and recover the cost.

Why This Matters Now

These provisions are often treated as boilerplate, but they directly control your company’s rights and remedies when a claim or dispute arises. By the time a problem surfaces, it is too late to renegotiate them.

Take Action Before You Sign

Before you sign or renew a commercial, supply, vendor, or construction contract, contact Rose Suriano or Robyn Lym for a review of your indemnification and warranty terms. They can help you:

  • Identify hidden or open-ended indemnification obligations
  • Confirm that your warranties, disclaimers, and remedy limits will hold up
  • Negotiate terms that allocate risk fairly and protect your recovery

Rose Suriano, Esq., Member, Litigation, rsuriano@bracheichler.com or 973.403.3129

Robyn K. Lym, Esq., Counsel, Litigation, rlym@bracheichler.com or 973.403.3124

*This is intended to provide general information, not legal advice. Please contact the authors if you need specific advice.

Related Practices:   Litigation

Related Attorney:   Rose Suriano, Robyn K. Lym

Related Industry:   Construction